On Mastodon, privacy belongs to the post, not the account
Mastodon’s posting documentation says post privacy on Mastodon is per post, rather than account-wide, and that there is no way to make past public posts private. A creator who tests the network with public posts and later wants a smaller audience cannot change that history by changing a setting.
This article offers a short check to run before you build an audience there: visibility, replies, discovery and move. It is editorial synthesis built from three Mastodon documentation pages, not a Mastodon feature and not a recommendation to use or avoid the network. The pages show last-updated dates of July 8, 2026 (posting), October 8, 2024 (promoting yourself and others) and November 27, 2025 (moving or leaving accounts), and Mastodon can change them. Your own server can also have its own rules, which these pages do not cover.
Visibility: pick the level before you post
The posting page lists four visibility levels: public, quiet public, followers and private mention. A public post can be seen at its permalink without logging in, appears in public timelines and on your profile, goes to followers’ home feeds and can be boosted. Quiet public is the same, except the post does not appear in live feeds or explore features and does not appear in search results, even if your account has opted in to full-text search.
A followers post is visible only to accounts following you and those mentioned, and cannot be boosted except by yourself. The page adds that to publish followers-only posts effectively you must disable the setting that automatically accepts new followers, otherwise anyone could follow you to view older posts. A private mention reaches only the people mentioned. The page warns not to share dangerous or sensitive information that way, because Mastodon is not an encrypted messaging app and the database administrators of the sender’s and recipient’s servers may obtain access to the text.
You can set a default visibility in your preferences and change it for each draft. Because there is no way back for a public post, the useful habit is to check the level on the draft, especially for anything you might later want to keep to a smaller group.
Replies: a reply is not the same as a new post that starts with a mention
The page says your replies will only appear on your followers’ home feeds if they follow both you and the person you are replying to. It adds that a new post that starts with an @mention is not considered a reply, so it appears on the home feed of all your followers, and that a reply’s visibility level does not affect whether it shows up on the home feed.
It also says that a public post containing a followed hashtag is shown on the home feed whether or not it is a reply, and that other software in the wider network may show all your replies on the home feed, whatever they reply to. For a creator, this means the same sentence can reach different people depending on how it is composed and what software they use. The page does not tell you who will actually see a particular post.
Discovery: three features that point people to your work
The promoting yourself page describes pinned posts, featured hashtags and the profile directory. You can pin up to five of your own public posts at the top of your posts tab. You can feature hashtags you use often, and your profile then shows a link to each hashtag with the date it was last used in a status and the number of statuses that used it. The profile directory shows accounts that have opted in, and can be sorted by recent activity or by new arrivals.
Two practical points follow from the pages. The pinning instructions refer to your own public posts, and quiet public, followers and private mention posts are hidden from public feeds, so a post you keep to a smaller group is probably not the one to use as a pinned introduction; check in your own app. The discovery page is the oldest of the three, last updated October 8, 2024, so check the current features in your own app. Related earlier coverage of a Bluesky automation label looks at account signals on another network.
Move: know what comes with you and what stays behind
The moving page says that if your server shuts down, changes policy or stops working for you, you can migrate your account to a new server and preserve much of your content and relationships. A profile move forces your followers to unfollow your current account and follow the new one if their software supports the Move activity. The page says your posts will not be moved because of technical limitations, that a 30-day cooldown applies before you can move again and that the move irreversibly forces everyone to unfollow the current account and follow the new one.
It also says moving does not automatically transfer your follows, blocks, mutes or bookmarks, which you can import from exported files. You can request an archive of your posts and media once every 7 days, downloaded in Activity Streams 2.0 JSON format. The page says Mastodon does not currently support importing posts or media. A profile redirect, by contrast, disables posting from the old account and shows a moved notice, and can be canceled. Deleting an account is irreversible and makes the profile and username forever unusable.
The page does not say how many followers will arrive, or how long the transfer will take, for any particular account. If your posts matter to you, keep your own copy, as in the earlier archive restore drill.
A hypothetical walkthrough
Imagine a newsletter writer who opens a Mastodon account and posts a draft announcement as public, then decides the first announcement should have gone to followers first. Under the pages above, the public post cannot be made private afterwards, so the writer’s check is to set the level on the draft, decide in advance which posts should be pinned and therefore public, and keep a copy of the text outside the platform.
If the writer later moves servers, the check says followers may follow across if their software supports the move, while the posts stay on the old server. For illustration only; the writer reads their own server rules and the current documentation first.
Keep a short record and check the pages again
Decide what each post is for before you choose its level. If you plan your content with a creator tool such as Launchvibes, add the intended audience and visibility to the idea so the post and the setting match. A post you can describe in one sentence is easier to place.
Keep a short record: the visibility you chose for each kind of post, which posts you pinned, which hashtags you feature, the date of your last archive request and the date you read Mastodon’s pages.
Check Mastodon’s current documentation and your server’s rules before you publish. This article reflects three documentation pages at the time of writing. It does not cover Mastodon’s pages on quoting posts, network features, dealing with unwanted content, preferences or profile setup, any server’s own rules or moderation, and it does not replace advice about your situation.